Thursday, 19 November 2026

Disaster at Flodden (again!)

 This week's game was my first venture back to the world of DBx games for many years.  I had a lengthy break from games in the late 90s/early 2000s when my son was born and life was a bit too busy for frivolities like gaming.  When I eventually decided to dip my toe back in the world of wargames I hunted around for a local club and found one not too far from home.

Now, before my extended sabbatical from gaming I'd played DBA and was aware of its big brother DBM.  I'd quite enjoyed DBA but on my return to gaming found DBM wasn't really my cup of team.  Too fiddly, with units hovering mm outside or inside of charge range, and the writing style... Barkerese... had been manageable in DBA but not for me when it grew into the bigger game.   The other big problem was that the club I'd found pretty much played DBM  exclusively and the members were all experts so most weeks (..actually every week!) resulted in a complete gubbing.  I don't mind losing but it quickly stopped being fun.  Luckily I quickly found the Guildford club where there was a lot more variety and things were a bit more fun!



So this week it was interesting to play DBA for the first time in many years.  The rules have now reached v3.0 but things still seemed very familiar. Except...

We were playing a variant adapted to allow the use of hexes.  In some ways this should make things easier and avoid the micro-measuring that used to infuriate me.  I think some of our struggles on the night were re-familiarising ourselves with the rules but the added complexity of hexes, doubled up units in a hex (which caused us headaches when units recoiled) and having to adapt the scale to match the hex size, led to lots of head scratching.




We were playing a sort-of Flodden refight using Anthony's lovely Wofun flats.  Despite the head-scratching the game was fun with the English longbow doing their historical job and driving back the Scots under the weight of the arrow storm.  2 out of 4 of my pike blocks managed to force their way through the arrows and hit the enemy.  One destroyed a unit of archers, but the other ran into some Men at Arms and recoiled back into their friends which lead to the destruction of some of my units and (in a very appropriate Scottish outcome) the death of James IV.  


the plucky Scots artillery which managed precisely one shot,
before being destroyed by the English gun!






The pikes about to charge home before the arrows drive them back


I'm not convinced we got everything right about the recoil rules (...not just sour grapes, Anthony honest!).  I know Anthony is planning another game with a square-based variant which might be clearer.

No comments:

Post a Comment